Equinox
Flower - Old music and new realities By Doron B. Cohen (Kyoto,
Japan)
Ozu's
bitter-sweet comedy, his first color film, wonderfully
realized and beautifully shot, includes one of
my favorite scenes in all his films.
Towards the last part of the film we see the mother
of the family, played by the great Tanaka Kinuyo,
sitting in her living room and enjoying nagauta
(a traditional way of singing, accompanied by
samisen, typical to the kabuki theater since the
18th century) being played on the radio. Her pleasure
is evident on her face as her eyes sparkle and
her neck performs light, rhythmical movements
to the music. We know that she is happy, because
earlier we've seen someone going to call her on
the phone and tell her that her husband (played
by Saburi Shin) finally agreed to the marriage
of their daughter to the man she loves (typically
to Ozu, we were not shown the actual phone conversation,
but we can guess that it took place by the mother's
good mood). Her happiness over the good news is
intensified by the pleasure she derives from the
music. However, she is not aware (and we are yet
to realize her unawareness) that her husband did
not give his consent of his own free will, but
was tricked into giving it. Then the grumpy husband
walks in and immediately turns off the radio.
The happy wife suddenly realizes that something
is wrong. After trying in vain to sooth his mood
she gives up on him and goes back to the radio
and turns it on, wishing to resume her pleasure
and to get rid of the bitter taste of his grumpiness
(and perhaps also secretly celebrate the triumph
over his stubbornness). But the husband shouts
at her to turn the radio off, demonstrating again
his selfishness and bad temper. She does as she's
told, while fixing him in a defiant stare. In
fact, the husband's triumph over the radio only
emphasizes how pathetic he became: this is the
only time in the whole film when his wish is triumphant.
In all other matters but the radio he is bitten
by his womenfolk: he agrees to the marriage against
his wish, he caves in and says he'll attend the
wedding after declaring it will take place without
his presence, and in the last scene he agrees
to go visit his daughter and make peace in spite
of himself.
There
is another striking case of the use of traditional
music in the film. In one of the last scenes,
the husband meets his old friends for a class
reunion. One of the friends (played by Chishu
Ryu) is urged by the others to sing a traditional
song. At first he refuses, saying that there is
no longer place for this old staff in contemporary
times, but eventually he relents. He sings an
old epic poem, typical of the pre-war period,
on the loyalty of a son to his father, and on
giving one's life at war. After singing a few
verses he stops and refuses to go on. The class-mates
then start singing a popular song from their school
days about the same theme. In the very last scene
the father is seen on the train, going to meet
his daughter, and quietly singing to himself the
same old song. Times have changed, he has to admit,
but it is still not easy for him to give up his
traditional values. In many ways, he is still
a man of the past. A little earlier his friend
told him that he had made peace with his own daughter,
who had eloped with her boyfriend (Saburi's earlier
attempt to bring about reconciliation between
father and daughter was another of his many failures
in this film; still, even when he realized the
danger of alienation between father and daughter,
he did not recognize the danger for himself, and
refused to allow his daughter to be married, only
because she chose the man without asking him first).
It is better to admit to the defeat of the old
generation, Ozu seems to say, and keep the family
together in spite of everything, hinting, perhaps,
also to Japan's defeat in the war and the need
to go along with modern sensibilities (including
the making of color films ). It is interesting
to note here also that in an earlier conversation
the wife said that she was happiest during the
war, in spite of all the hardships, because then
the whole family was together; the husband, as
usual, disagrees, but perhaps he learns better.
The
film opens with a scene at a railway station,
with attendants talking about the many newlywed
couples boarding trains. This is followed by a
wedding scene, in which Saburi gives a speech,
praising the new idea of love-marriage, and then
goes on to contradict himself when it comes to
his own daughter. The film ends on the train,
with the father going to meet his daughter for
a final reconciliation. Another director would
have shown us the meeting (or the wedding, or
both), and squeeze out some more emotion and tears
from the scene. But Ozu have already told us -
or rather, showed us - everything he had to tell
and show, sending us home with a little smile
on our face, and perhaps a little tear in our
heart.